Smartest Doc
Three-year results of randomised clinical trial comparing lightweight mesh with heavyweight mesh for inguinal hernioplasty
Hernia, 07/17/2012
Clinical Article
Nikkolo C et al. – The study shows that compared with heavyweight mesh (HW) mesh, LW mesh has no advantage in reducing chronic groin pain and foreign body feeling at the operation site after inguinal hernioplasty at 3–year follow–up. Severe preoperative pain was correlated with the development of chronic pain. There was no difference between the two study groups in the recurrence rates.
Methods- The patients were randomised into the heavyweight mesh (HW) group and lightweight mesh (LW) group.
- A tension–free mesh repair using the Lichtenstein technique was performed on all patients. Pain scores during different activities were measured on visual analogue scale.
- All patients underwent a clinical examination for any evidence of hernia recurrence.
- Of the patients, 17.2 % in the HW group and 29.3 % in the LW group reported that they experienced pain at 3–year follow–up (P = 0.1323).
- Pain was most often reported during physical activity.
- The median VAS score of all studied activities was 30.5 in the HW group and 30.0 in the LW group.
- There were more patients in the HW group than in the LW group who stated that they could feel the mesh in the groin (27.6 vs. 20.7 %, P = 0.3967).
- Among all patients, 42.9 % who had severe pain preoperatively also reported pain during different activities and 19.6 % of the patients who did not have severe pain preoperatively reported pain during different activities (P = 0.0481).
- At 3–year follow–up, there was 1 hernia recurrence in the HW group and 1 hernia recurrence in the LW group.
