Psychiatry Medical News about Pain Psychological Techniques

Become a Member Today!
Register

Most Viewed Abstracts

1. Report Shows Shift in Starting Salaries for Physicians

2. 2008 Exclusive Survey—Earnings: Good news for primary care income

3. Medicare pay-for-reporting effort draws fire from frustrated doctors

4. Debunking Myths in the US Healthcare System

5. Omega-3 fatty acids for bipolar disorder

Your Article Summary

See Latest Articles

(Click the title below to leave the MDLinx Network and go to the Journal's Website)

Review: limited evidence that psychological therapies are of benefit for adults with chronic pain
Evidence-Based Mental Health, 10/28/09

Feinmann C – CBT may have a weak effect in improving pain, mood and disability in adults with chronic pain. There is an absence of evidence for BT, except for pain immediately following treatment, compared with TAU.

Methods

Systematic review with meta–analysis. Data sources: The Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, MEDLINE, EMBASE and Psychlit (from database inception to January 2008; an update search was later made up to August 2008).
Published randomised controlled trials (RCTs) comparing any psychological treatment with placebo, waiting list control, or medical or physical treatment for adults (aged >18 years) with chronic pain (>=3 months’ duration; any site of the body).
Two reviewers independently assessed quality and included studies based on consensus agreement.
Studies were classified as cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) or behavioural therapy (BT) compared with active control (AC) or treatment as usual (TAU).
Outcomes were assessed immediately post–treatment or at follow–up (between 6 and 12 months post–treatment).

Results

40 studies (n = 4781) met the inclusion criteria.
14 studies were of treatments for low back pain; 14 included mixed groups of musculoskeletal pain, including low back pain; nine were for rheumatoid arthritis; six were for fibromyalgia; four for temporomandibular joint pain; two for osteoarthritis of the knee; one for upper limb pain; and one for shoulder pain.
Follow–up was complete for between 53% and 100% of subjects with an overall completion rate of 84%.
Mean sample size for each trial was 81 (mean 75% female), mean age 48.7 years and chronic pain had been present for a median 9.9 months.
CBT was not effective compared with AC immediately post–treatment for treating chronic pain or mood but had a small effect on disability (12 RCTs, 728 participants). At follow–up, CBT reduced pain compared with AC (12 RCTs, 935 participants), improved mood (12 RCTs, 934 participants) and reduced disability (11 RCTs, 876 participants).
CBT reduced pain compared with TAU immediately post–treatment (23 studies, 1199 participants) but did not improve mood or affect disability. At follow–up, CBT was no longer effective compared with TAU for pain or disability but had a small significant effect on mood (nine RCTs, 684 participants).
BT did not significantly reduce pain compared with AC either immediately post–treatment or at follow–up, improve mood or affect disability. Compared with TAU, BT reduced pain immediately post–treatment (nine RCTs, 430 participants) but had no effect on disability. At follow–up, BT had no significant effects on any outcome compared with TAU.