Efficacy versus Effectiveness: A Direct Comparison of the Outcome of Treatment for Mild to Moderate Depression in Randomized Controlled Trials and Daily Practice
Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics,  Clinical Article

van der Lem R et al. – Effectiveness of treatment for mild–to–moderate major depressive disorder in daily practice is similar to STAR*D and significantly lower than efficacy results from randomized controlled trials.

Methods
  • Effectiveness in routine clinical practice was compared with efficacy results from 15 meta-analyses on antidepressant, psychotherapeutic and combination treatment and results from STAR*D.
  • Data on daily practice patients and treatments were derived from a routine outcome monitoring (ROM) system.
  • Treatment outcome was defined as proportion of remitters (MADRS ≤10) and within-group effect size.

Results
  • From ROM, 598 patients suffering from a MDD episode according to the MINI-plus were included.
  • Remission percentages were lower in routine practice than in meta-analyses for all treatment modalities (32 vs.40-74%).
  • Differences were less explicit for antidepressants (21 vs. 34-47%) than for individual psychotherapy (27 vs. 34-58%; effect size 0.85 vs. 1.71) and combination therapy (21 vs. 45-63%), since only 60% of the meta-analyses for antidepressants showed significant differences with ROM, while for psychotherapy and combination treatment almost all meta-analyses showed significant differences.
  • No differences in effectiveness were found between routine practice and STAR*D (antidepressants 27 vs. 28%; individual psychotherapy 27 vs. 25%; combination treatment 21 vs. 23%, respectively).

Please login or register to follow this author.
Are you sure you want to Unfollow this Author?
► Click here to access PubMed, Publisher and related articles...
<< Previous Article | Next Article >>

Your Unread Messages in Psychiatry

See All >> Messages include industry-sponsored communications and special communications from MDLinx

Most Popular Psychiatry Articles

1 Atypical antipsychotics olanzapine, quetiapine, and risperidone and risk of acute major cardiovascular events in young and middle-aged adults: A nationwide register-based cohort study in Denmark CNS Drugs, June 18, 2014    Clinical Article

2 Comparative efficacy and tolerability of 15 antipsychotic drugs in schizophrenia: A multiple-treatments meta-analysis FOCUS, June 16, 2014    Evidence Based Medicine

3 Vitamin D supplementation for depressive symptoms: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials Psychosomatic Medicine, March 20, 2014    Evidence Based Medicine    Review Article    Clinical Article

4 Re-evaluating the role of antidepressants in cancer-related depression: A systematic review and meta-analysis General Hospital Psychiatry, June 4, 2014    Evidence Based Medicine

5 Does pharmacological treatment of ADHD in adults enhance parenting performance?: Results of a double-blind randomized trial CNS Drugs, June 12, 2014    Clinical Article

6 Association between C-reactive protein and depression: modulated by gender and mediated by body weight Psychiatry Research, June 19, 2014    Clinical Article

7 A comparison of the effects of hatha yoga and resistance exercise on mental health and well-being in sedentary adults: A pilot study Complementary Therapies in Medicine, June 20, 2014    Clinical Article

8 Attachment anxiety is related to epstein-barr virus latency Brain, Behavior, and Immunity, June 23, 2014    Clinical Article

9 Pretreatment brain states identify likely nonresponse to standard treatments for depression Biological Psychiatry, May 23, 2014    Clinical Article

10 Physical diseases among persons with obsessive compulsive symptoms and disorder: A general population study Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology, June 13, 2014    Clinical Article

11 Efficacy of adjunctive aripiprazole in patients with major depressive disorder whose symptoms worsened with antidepressant monotherapy CNS Spectrums, May 30, 2014    Clinical Article

12 Drug treatment for attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder and suicidal behaviour: register based study BMJ, June 24, 2014    Evidence Based Medicine    Clinical Article

13 A randomized, double-blind evaluation of D-cycloserine or alprazolam combined with virtual reality exposure therapy for posttraumatic stress disorder in Iraq and Afghanistan war veterans American Journal of Psychiatry, June 9, 2014    Clinical Article

14 A positive association between anxiety disorders and cannabis use or cannabis use disorders in the general population- A meta-analysis of 31 studies Full Text BMC Psychiatry, May 20, 2014    Free full text    Evidence Based Medicine    Clinical Article

15 Predicting autism diagnosis by 7 years of age using parent report of infant social communication skills Journal of Paediatrics and Child Health, June 10, 2014    Clinical Article

16 Risk of myocardial infarction and stroke in bipolar disorder: A systematic review and exploratory meta-analysis Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, June 2, 2014    Evidence Based Medicine    Review Article

17 Myofascial pain in war veterans with post-traumatic stress disorder Journal of Musculoskeletal Pain , June 11, 2014    Clinical Article

18 Topiramate as an adjuvant treatment for obsessive compulsive symptoms in patients with bipolar disorder: A randomized double blind placebo controlled clinical trial Journal of Affective Disorders, June 9, 2014    Clinical Article

19 Elevated fetal steroidogenic activity in autism Full Text Molecular Psychiatry, June 25, 2014    Free full text    Clinical Article

20 Eveningness and insomnia: independent risk factors of nonremission in major depressive disorder SLEEP, May 7, 2014    Clinical Article

Indexed Journals in Psychiatry : Current Psychiatry, Bipolar Disorders, American Journal of Psychiatry, Addictionmore

Register now to view all the MDLinx contents (FREE)!

  • Stay current on the latest literature, research and clinical news
  • Get special communications and offers from MDLinx and our sponsors
  • Receive invitations to paid market research
View Samples and Register

Connect with us, stay current.

Receive the latest mecial news
updates for free via email

Sign up!

Subscribe to our free RSS feeds:

Get the latest news in your specialty automatically added to your newsreader or your personal My Yahoo!, Google, My MSN or My AOL page. Learn More

Close