Smartest Doc
Use of Kiosks and Patient Understanding of Opt-out and Opt-in Consent for Routine Rapid Human Immunodeficiency Virus Screening in the Emergency Department
Academic Emergency Medicine, 03/29/2012
Haukoos JS et al. – Computerized kiosks can be successfully used to perform nontargeted rapid HIV screening in emergency department (ED). However, when using this approach, patient understanding of opt–in consent is significantly better than opt–out consent.
Methods- This study was a prospective quasi-experiment in an urban hospital with an annual ED and urgent care census of 120,000 visits.
- During medical screening, patients 13years and older were offered rapid HIV screening using kiosks and opt-out consent (October 2009) or opt-in consent (December 2009).
- Random time blocks were used to administer structured surveys to evaluate patient understanding of the testing process.
- During the opt-out phase, 6,602 were offered testing, and of these 3,993 (61%) did not opt-out and 886 (13%) completed screening.
- During the opt-in phase, 5,781 were offered testing, and of these 930 (16%) opted-in and 389 (7%) completed screening (absolute difference=6%, 95% confidence interval [CI]=5% to 8%).
- During the opt-out phase, 330 patients completed the survey.
- Of these, 201 (61%) did not opt-out, but 108 (54%, 95% CI=47% to 61%) responded that they had not been informed about an HIV test.
- Of the 84 patients who had been informed, 32 (38%, 95% CI=28% to 49%) responded that they had not agreed to an HIV test.
- During the opt-in phase, 416 completed the survey.
- Of these, 80 (19%) agreed to testing and two (3%, 95% CI=0.3% to 9%) responded that they had not been informed about an HIV test.
- Of the 74 patients who had been informed, only two (3%, 95% CI=0.3% to 9%) responded that they had not agreed to an HIV test.