Are the public ready for organ donation after out of hospital cardiac arrest

Emergency Medicine Journal, 04/27/2012

Bruce CM et al. – The majority of patients and their relatives are not averse to organ donation (OD) being discussed shortly after Emergency Department (ED) death. Organ preservation procedures are acceptable to many. Prior discussion and prior organ donor registration may improve acceptability.


  • 200 questionnaires were completed.
  • 37.5% of participants were male subjects; mean age was 40.4 (SD 16.9; range 15-85)years.


  • There was no difference in the number willing to discuss OD after brainstem death in intensive care unit compared with circulatory death in the ED (72% vs 72%; p=0.146).
  • The majority were willing to discuss OD soon after ED death after cardiac arrest (106; 54%).
  • 41 (21%) were not willing and 43 (22%) had no strong views (n=198).
  • Organ preservation procedures (groin tube insertion, continuation of mechanical cardiopulmonary resuscitation and continuation of ventilator) were acceptable to between 48% and 57% of respondents if performed before discussion with family increasing to an acceptability of between 64% and 69% after discussion with family.
  • One in four respondents felt these procedures were not acceptable regardless of the timing of discussion with family and some felt these procedures were more acceptable if the patient was a registered organ donor.
  • 122 (61%) patients wished to donate their organs after death but only 59 (30%) were registered donors.

Print Article Summary Cat 2 CME Report